Best Nursing Homes in Payson, AZ

Top 10 nursing homes and skilled nursing facilities in Payson, Arizona, ranked by Dorthea Index score. 11 total providers are rated in Payson, AZ. Scores are based on verified CMS data — no provider pays for its ranking.

1. Hospice Compassus-Payson — 85/100 (Strong (80–89))
511 South Mudspring Road, Suite #1, Payson, AZ 85541
Hospice Compassus-Payson scores above average nationally, with 0.25 nurse hours per resident-day. View full profile
2. Banner Home Care - Payson — 73/100 (Average (65–79))
708 East Route 260, Suite A1, Payson, AZ 85541
Banner Home Care - Payson scores in the Average range nationally. View full profile
3. Hospice Of Payson, Llc — 66/100 (Average (65–79))
900 North Beeline Highway, Suite B, Payson, AZ 85541
Hospice Of Payson, Llc scores in the Average range nationally. View full profile
4. Payson Care Center — 61/100 (Below Average (50–64))
107 East Lone Pine Drive, Payson, AZ 85541
Payson Care Center scores below the national average for nursing home quality. View full profile
5. Ordinary Lifestyles, Llc Iii — 50/100 (Below Average (50–64))
207 East Zurich, Payson, AZ 85541
Ordinary Lifestyles, Llc Iii scores below the national average for nursing home quality. View full profile
6. The Frontier House — 50/100 (Below Average (50–64))
906 East Frontier Street, Payson, AZ 85541
The Frontier House scores below the national average for nursing home quality. View full profile
7. Avista Senior Living Payson — 50/100 (Below Average (50–64))
806 West Longhorn Road, Payson, AZ 85541
Avista Senior Living Payson scores below the national average for nursing home quality. View full profile
8. Ordinary Lifestyles Ii — 50/100 (Below Average (50–64))
718 North Fox Hill, Payson, AZ 85541
Ordinary Lifestyles Ii scores below the national average for nursing home quality. View full profile
9. Ordinary Lifestyles Iv — 50/100 (Below Average (50–64))
205 West Bonita, Payson, AZ 85541
Ordinary Lifestyles Iv scores below the national average for nursing home quality. View full profile
10. Ordinary Lifestyles — 50/100 (Below Average (50–64))
401 North Laredo Lane, Payson, AZ 85541
Ordinary Lifestyles scores below the national average for nursing home quality. View full profile

Data source: CMS Nursing Home Care database. Scored by Dorthea Index using five independently verified components: 30-day readmission rate (25%), staffing consistency (25%), 5-star rating trend (20%), inspection record (20%), and long-stay quality measures (10%).

See all Arizona providers