Best Nursing Homes in New Castle, IN

Top 7 nursing homes and skilled nursing facilities in New Castle, Indiana, ranked by Dorthea Index score. 7 total providers are rated in New Castle, IN. Scores are based on verified CMS data — no provider pays for its ranking.

1. Henry County Memorial Hospital Hospice — 86/100 (Strong (80–89))
798 N 16th Street, New Castle, IN 47362
Henry County Memorial Hospital Hospice scores above average nationally, with 0.39 nurse hours per resident-day. View full profile
2. Hickory Creek At New Castle — 70/100 (Average (65–79))
901 N 16th Street, New Castle, IN 47362
Hickory Creek At New Castle scores in the Average range nationally, with 10 citations in the last 36 months. View full profile
3. Glen Oaks Health Campus — 69/100 (Average (65–79))
601 W Cr 200 S, New Castle, IN 47362
Glen Oaks Health Campus scores in the Average range nationally, with 9 citations in the last 36 months. View full profile
4. Stonebrooke Rehabilitation Center — 59/100 (Below Average (50–64))
990 N 16th St, New Castle, IN 47362
Stonebrooke Rehabilitation Center scores below the national average for nursing home quality. View full profile
5. Waters Of New Castle, The — 59/100 (Below Average (50–64))
1000 N 16th St, New Castle, IN 47362
Waters Of New Castle, The scores below the national average for nursing home quality. View full profile
6. Willows Of New Castle — 49/100 (Concerning (below 50))
1023 N 20th St, New Castle, IN 47362
Willows Of New Castle scores below the national average for nursing home quality. View full profile
7. Hcmh Home Care — 46/100 (Concerning (below 50))
798 N 16th Street, New Castle, IN 47362
Hcmh Home Care scores below the national average for nursing home quality. View full profile

Data source: CMS Nursing Home Care database. Scored by Dorthea Index using five independently verified components: 30-day readmission rate (25%), staffing consistency (25%), 5-star rating trend (20%), inspection record (20%), and long-stay quality measures (10%).

See all Indiana providers